|
|
Post by celticladies on Nov 6, 2007 12:47:16 GMT
I can tell you what I think! Normal. I love her outfit! Looks like she is so happy, in a really good way.  This is Cathy.  This is Herself.  |
|
|
|
Post by Nordly on Nov 6, 2007 13:10:19 GMT
where's a pic of her being Hayley doing it?
|
|
|
|
Post by roger on Nov 6, 2007 14:05:50 GMT
Hi Celticladies, It's kinda interesting to see Hayley dressed up as someone else, like Cathy for example, but I think we all prefer to see her as herself.  Roger |
|
|
|
Post by Richard on Nov 6, 2007 15:06:02 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by Nordly on Nov 6, 2007 19:38:46 GMT
hey CL! I love Hayley as Hayley because Hayley is Hayley in so many hairstyles and outfits- and the Cathy pic is just not her! Sorry CL! And thanks for adding the pic of her singing as Hayley.
|
|
Joe
Administrator
Supporting Hayley since 2003!
Posts: 6,701 
|
Post by Joe on Nov 7, 2007 4:44:41 GMT
I really like Hayley singing as Cathy, but not as much as Hayley herself singing as Cathy.
Joe
|
|
|
|
Post by milewalker on Nov 11, 2007 16:51:17 GMT
I am the person who voted for Cathy.
I must admit that I am a bit confused by many of the comments above. The video represents a cimematic interpretation of the music, and is therefore by definition somewhat more visual. Nevertheless if this were a part of a musical, it would be very easy to see Hayley in the role
To be fair, most songs are generic. A song like "Tonight" for example can stand on its own as a love song and therefore can be sung in concert by anyone. It isnt necessary to know the plot of West Side Story to interpret the song. Wuthering Heights is different. The song makes no sense at all out of context. For this reason, I dont think you can easily separate the role from the song in this case.
When I watched Live in New Zealand I was struck by the contrast in the stage persona Hayley exihibited in this song when compared to the rest of the concert. I wasnt the only one who noted that - the PBS presenters were clearly bored with the concert up until the point at which she sang this. The performance drew raves, and I think the reason this happened was that to some extent, she did step into the role of Cathy, (who is quite literally a "free spirt") and was in fact quite impressive in doing so.
Jon
|
|
|
|
Post by graemek on Nov 14, 2007 2:57:48 GMT
Yes Jon,
She was magnificent in that song.
However, I found her magnificent in that whole concert.
We both (my wife & I) "found" her in that concert.
It was on TV one Sunday afternoon & we were really desperate afterwards to find "who is she?".
Well, we found out !!!!!
And we still are finding out......speechless.
Graeme
PS I voted for her being herself.
|
|
