Post by Richard on Apr 29, 2007 7:53:39 GMT
Hello everybody!
This album may only be available in Malaysia, because I've found this review from the Malaysia Star:-
[/b] VARIOUS ARTISTES
(Universal)
Reviewer: LI EE KEE
EVER wondered what the “voice of romance” sounds like? Well, wonder no more. Here, in this compilation album are 20 prime examples, with voices that range from operatic to jazzy, bluesy and pop-ish.
Although I must say that the selection of some of these “voices” left me baffled. The Choirboys, All Angels or Trinity hardly left me intoxicated with feelings of love and yearning for a heady romance. Instead, for some strange reason, I felt the need to go to church.
And, if like me, you decide to listen to the album after gobbling down a heavy lunch, it is likely that some of these “voices” will lull you into a slumber. No disrespect to the singers and their voices. I believe they were just bogged down by the songs. Wouldn’t it have made more sense to feature their original material instead?
Baritone Patrizio Buanne’s Un Angelo isn’t too bad but it just doesn’t have the same fervour as Robbie Williams’ original. Bedshaped (Cosi) by tenor Vittorio Grigolo is interesting at best but give me Keane’s rendition any day. Welsh mezzo-soprano Katherine Jenkins’ cover of Bryan Adams’ (Everything I Do) I Do It for You is downright weird.
There are times when things should just be left the way they are. In this case, the operatic treatment on these contemporary pop tunes is an experiment gone awry.
Fortunately, there are more than enough decent tunes here to save the album from total disgrace. Like Andrea Bocelli’s Besame Mucho, Careless Love by Madeleine Peyroux, Hayley Westenra’s Pokarekare Ana, and English tenor Russell Watson’s version of You Raise Me Up. Luciano Pavarotti’s Nessun Dorma! and Tony Bennett’s The Most Beautiful Girl in the World.
Overall, this is a mixed bag that might just suit your palate, but I’m sure it could have been done better.[/size][/quote]
This album is a very strange mixture, so Universal must be targeting a wide audience!
Richard
This album may only be available in Malaysia, because I've found this review from the Malaysia Star:-
Voices of Romance
Artist:
Artist:
(Universal)
Reviewer: LI EE KEE
EVER wondered what the “voice of romance” sounds like? Well, wonder no more. Here, in this compilation album are 20 prime examples, with voices that range from operatic to jazzy, bluesy and pop-ish.
Although I must say that the selection of some of these “voices” left me baffled. The Choirboys, All Angels or Trinity hardly left me intoxicated with feelings of love and yearning for a heady romance. Instead, for some strange reason, I felt the need to go to church.
And, if like me, you decide to listen to the album after gobbling down a heavy lunch, it is likely that some of these “voices” will lull you into a slumber. No disrespect to the singers and their voices. I believe they were just bogged down by the songs. Wouldn’t it have made more sense to feature their original material instead?
Baritone Patrizio Buanne’s Un Angelo isn’t too bad but it just doesn’t have the same fervour as Robbie Williams’ original. Bedshaped (Cosi) by tenor Vittorio Grigolo is interesting at best but give me Keane’s rendition any day. Welsh mezzo-soprano Katherine Jenkins’ cover of Bryan Adams’ (Everything I Do) I Do It for You is downright weird.
There are times when things should just be left the way they are. In this case, the operatic treatment on these contemporary pop tunes is an experiment gone awry.
Fortunately, there are more than enough decent tunes here to save the album from total disgrace. Like Andrea Bocelli’s Besame Mucho, Careless Love by Madeleine Peyroux, Hayley Westenra’s Pokarekare Ana, and English tenor Russell Watson’s version of You Raise Me Up. Luciano Pavarotti’s Nessun Dorma! and Tony Bennett’s The Most Beautiful Girl in the World.
Overall, this is a mixed bag that might just suit your palate, but I’m sure it could have been done better.[/size][/quote]
This album is a very strange mixture, so Universal must be targeting a wide audience!
Richard